The
news of a memorandum of understanding between the United States and Iran has
set-off a huge political backlash in Israel. The interim deal that will be
formally inked on June 19 at Switzerland, aimed at ending current hostilities
and paving the way for 60-days of talks to negotiate a final agreement, is
largely seen as a major strategic setback for Israel.
The
“Together” party chairman and former Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennet, who
leads the principal opposition front along with former Israeli Prime Minister
Yair Lapid, in a press meet on Monday termed the US-Iran MoU as Netanyahu government’s historic failure against Iran.
Yair Lapid blasted the interim deal to be “one of the most
shocking failures in Israel’s foreign and security policy entirely registered
in Netanyahu’s name.”
Yair Golan, the centre-left party leader and former Israeli
general, posted on X “Trump signs an agreement that funnels billions to the
Ayatollahs’ regime, leaves the nuclear infrastructure intact, preserves the
ballistic threat as is, and throws a lifeline to the murderous regime in
Tehran”.
Former Prime Minister and a challenger to Netanyahu
Ehud Barak said in an interview with Israel’s public broadcaster Monday “Israel
is paying the price of Netanyahu’s hubris and
blindness, and the
price of the manipulations that he tried to pull on Trump. Iran emerged
stronger; Israel emerged weaker. That is Netanyahu’s strategic responsibility.
He failed.”
Even
members of Netanyahu-led ruling alliance are extremely miffed and concerned for
the political fallout. The Far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir
has rejected the deal, saying Israel was
not bound by it in any way. “We must not compromise on anything less than the
dismantling of Hezbollah,” Ben-Gvir, wrote on X.
Failure to trigger a regime change in Iran
It
was assumed that the Feb 28 US-Israeli military operation would be powerful
enough to trigger a regime change in Iran, given the widespread Iranian
protests in December and January.
For
decades, Netanyahu had made removal
of the Islamic Republic in Iran a key rallying point in his political career. He is believed to
have convinced Trump on this with Israeli intelligence input.
After
eliminating the Supreme Leader and dozens of key Iranian officials on day one
of the military operation, in a video address US President Donald Trump appealed Iranians to seize the opportunity and overthrow the
government. Effort was made to foment an armed uprising with the aid of Iranian
Kurdish separatists.
Now,
the US-Iran MOU legitimises the same Islamic regime it had set out to
obliterate, strengthening it as never before with massive reconstruction fund
and sweeping sanction relief.
On Monday during a press meet when asked the reason for his failure to
bring about collapse of the Iranian regime, Netanyahu angrily retorted back
that “regime change” was never his stated goal.
But
it is very unlikely that the Iranian public will buy his arguments now,
contradicting his own political stance for decades.
The
Israeli opposition has begun cashing on this, widely perceived as a major
security and strategic failure of Benjamin Netanyahu who leads the most-right
wing alliance ever and voted on the promise of degrading the Iranian regime &
its axis.
“The clock for regime change
in Iran will start as soon as the government in Israel is changed”, former
Israeli Prime Minister Natali Bennet said on Monday who heads the key
opposition ‘Together” party emerging as the frontrunner in most recent opinion
polls.
"In the face of the Iranian axis of
evil - we will renew with all our might the "octopus doctrine" that
we began to implement in the government headed by me. On the one hand, we
prevent Iran from going nuclear, and on the other hand, we accelerate the
collapse of the regime with political, economic, technological and military
tools.”, Bennet said.
Little impact on Iranian Missile and Nuclear
capabilities
At
the Monday press meet Netanyahu brushing aside the failure to cause “regime
change” in Iran, claimed to have saved Israel from an imminent “nuclear annihilation”. The key objectives of the US-Israeli
operation have been achieved; we have removed the “nuclear danger” and the
“ballistic missile danger” from Iran, Netanyahu claimed.
He
said Israel was much safer now than it was on October 7 2023 when Hamas
launched the carnage. But lamented that
there was an organized, systematic effort to minimize these enormous
achievements, to avoid showing that Israel is emerging renewed, strong and
steadfast.
However, most expert assessments seem to differ.
A CNN investigation last month
found that Iran has successfully replenished its missile capabilities post the
38-days intense strike by US and Israel.
CNN found that Iran has now unblocked 50 out of the 69 tunnel entrances struck by the US and
Israel at 18 underground missile facilities. Experts believe Iran still has
thousands of missiles in its underground missile sites and is fast rebuilding
the destroyed missile factories and supply chain.
According to experts, Iran’s missile stockpile buried hundreds
of metres beneath the surface, is unlikely to have sustained much damage from
strikes at ground level, given that the US and Israeli military struck tunnel
entrances. For decades, Iran has been building numerous sophisticated underground
missile cities
beneath mountains and deserts in almost all provinces and cities.
This is why Netanyahu wanted the US-Israeli strike on Iran to
continue for long. Beyond political rhetoric, he knows well Iran’s missile
capabilities remains largely intact and now the US-Iran MOU ending the war
would give them enough room to accelerate the program further.
On Iran’s nuclear status, details trickling in of the MOU is
giving strong indication that the issue of enrichment will be negotiated at a
later stage with Iran making it clear that under no circumstance the enriched
uranium would be allowed to be taken out of the country.
Strategic windfall for Iran
The US-Israeli strike has handed over Iran two very significant
point of leverage – the strait of Hormuz and the vulnerability of the Gulf States, United States’s key allies in
the region hosting US military bases.
Given that it has successfully used this pressure points to
manoeuvre the United States and choke the global economy, its strategic strength has
grown manyfold as compared to the beginning of the war.
The resilience of the Iranian people in the face of a massive
attack by two of world’s most powerful military, sustaining 38-days of brutal
aerial campaign and hitting back as never expected has added a new strategic
depth to the deterrence framework of Iran.
The MOU widely speculated to include immediate sanction relief
on sale of Iranian oil, unfreezing of Iranian assets frozen in foreign banks
and a reconstruction fund of 300 billion dollar will be seen as a
disproportionate trade-off to desperately exit a conflict inflicting enormous
cost on the United States.
The whole military campaign and the interim peace deal is seen a
windfall for Iran and a strategic defeat for the Israel.
The opinion polls in Israel
According to the latest weekly poll published
on Friday by Hebrew-language daily Maariv, the Netanyahu-led Likud party is dropping by
three seats to just 22. To form a
government in Israel, a party or coalition must secure at least 61 seats in the 120-member Israeli parliament Knesset.
This is Likud Party’s lowest figure since
August 2025, when it received 21 seats in a Maariv poll.
However, the Netanyahu-led 5 party ruling coalition bloc maintained its
strength from last week at 50 seats. The Zionist opposition bloc remained at 60
seats, and the Arab parties received an additional 10 seats.
In the opposition, Gadi Eisenkot’s strengthening
trend continued, with his party Yashar! jumping three seats this week to a
record 20. Conversely, the Together party, led by Naftali Bennett, fell by two
seats to 21. In effect, a three-way race has emerged for the title of the
largest party among Likud, Together, and Yashar!
In a bloc-based
distribution, the coalition wins 53 seats and the opposition 67. However, the
opposition bloc also includes 11 seats from the Arab parties. This means that
the non-Arab opposition parties only reach 56 seats, so they alone will still
have difficulty forming a government.
The road ahead for Netanyahu
Netanyahu’s approval
rating has plunged almost 30% since the Feb 28 Iran war. A Channel 12 poll in first week of June found
only 32% approving Netanyahu to retain the premiership while 58 percent of respondents saying another
candidate should be the premier.
Polls after signing of the US-Iran MOU could be
catastrophic for Netanyahu.
However, his military campaign in Lebanon is
expected to be the make-or-break outcome. He can undo some of the damages from
the Iran front if he is successful in containing the Hizbollah and holding on
to the southern Lebanon, now under Israeli occupation.
To succeed in Lebanon, he has to confront Trump
as the MOU most likely includes an immediate ceasefire in Lebanon and Israeli withdrawal
from the occupied Southern parts. He can’t anger Trump as his support is
crucial for the upcoming election. On other front, his electoral prospects now
very much hinge on the Northern Israel where his
popularity has plummeted for failure to curtail the Hizbollah threat.
Election in Israel must be held by end of this October.